Plaza Pizza: The Stand-Out Pizza in Newark, Ohio

For more than 50 years, Plaza Pizza has been a family favorite for pizza in Newark, Ohio. That’s saying something, because pizza in Newark is taken very seriously by its residents. For Plaza Pizza to be considered some of the best pizza in Newark, it has to be delicious.

THE HISTORY OF PLAZA PIZZA IN NEWARK, OHIO

Plaza Pizza was started in 1971 as just another mom and pop pizza restaurant when independent pizza places were in virtually every neighborhood. Because of their traditional recipes, handmade thin crust with a satisfying crunch, and exceptional service, Plaza Pizza distinguished itself quickly from other Newark pizza options. For 5 decades, Plaza Pizza has been a staple part of family gatherings, celebrations, and weekend get-togethers. People who grew up with Plaza Pizza in Newark, Ohio and then moved away made going to Plaza Pizza a must during return visits. This pizza has a loyal following, and it’s only going to get better.

Three people in red shirts are posing for a picture.

Plaza Pizza in Newark, Ohio has New Owners

The Claggett family grew up loving Plaza Pizza. No matter how far they ventured as adults, one taste of Plaza Pizza’s delectable slices, and they knew they were back home. The thin, flaky crusts offer a satisfying crunch, and the proprietary sauce is full of flavor and one of the reasons Plaza Pizza is such a beloved part of the Newark, Ohio pizza scene. In 2019, the original owners decided it was time to hang up their aprons and retire. The Claggett children, Brian, Ben, and Olivia, didn’t want to lose an institution for pizza in Newark, Ohio. They came together to take over the brand, and it’s been a responsibility the children have taken very seriously. Under the leadership of Brian, Ben, and Olivia, along with input from the entire Claggett family, Plaza Pizza has a fresh future and several upgrades to how they operate. Previously, fans of Plaza Pizza needed to call to place their order, and would have to make sure they had the cash to pay for their pizza. The internet and debit or credit cards have long changed the way consumers order and pay for goods. Having available cash for pizza has become less and less common. The Claggetts now accept card payments and Plaza Pizza can be ordered online. The Claggetts may be new owners of Plaza Pizza in Newark, Ohio, but the restaurant is still family-owned and operated, serving the quality pizza residents of Newark have come to love. The difference is, now Plaza Pizza is more convenient than ever.

Plaza Pizza has an Expanded Menu

It’s not just logistics that have improved for Plaza Pizza in Newark, Ohio either. The Claggetts are still serving up Plaza Pizza classics, so residents aren’t losing their beloved favorites. But Americans are also refining their pizza preferences, and the Claggetts are listening. The menu has been updated to meet the needs of the modern diet. If you need a low-carb or keto option, Plaza Pizza in Newark, Ohio can deliver, and so can their second location in Heath, Ohio. The new cauliflower crust is already a favorite of Plaza Pizza loyalists because it still delivers on the Plaza Pizza promise of tasty, thin crust pizza while also being appropriate for specific diets and low-carb requirements. Plaza Pizza in Newark, Ohio has also added new flavors to the menu that are sure to become new classics, like the BLT pizza, the BBQ chicken, and the Buffalo Chicken pizzas. There’s even a dessert pizza called the Shirley Lou, after the Claggett’s late grandmother, that invokes the feeling of home in its hot, house-made apple pie filling, streusel topping, and icing drizzled over the top. In addition to pizza, the Plaza Pizza menu boasts salads and a torpedo sandwich that has to be tasted to be believed. Alongside garlic bread and cheesy garlic bread, it’s a complete meal. With 17 traditional and updated toppings, the proprietary sauce recipe, and Plaza Pizza’s signature thin crust with the cracker crunch, there’s something on the menu for everyone to love.

Plaza Pizza Preserving Tradition and Building a Future

The original Plaza Pizza captured the hearts of those in Newark, Ohio and beyond. The Claggett family is dedicated to continuing to serve made-to-order pizzas that customers have loved for generations. They’re also looking to bring everything people love about Plaza Pizza into the 21st century with more convenient ordering and payment options, as well as updated flavors and crusts that everyone can enjoy. Brian, Ben, and Olivia have fond memories of having Plaza Pizza as a staple at their family gatherings and important celebrations, as well as regular dinners when pizza just hit the spot. They’re committed to preserving the Plaza Pizza reputation while also giving the institution the upgrades that will make ordering, paying, and enjoying that much easier. With a second location in Heath, Ohio, the Claggetts are bringing Plaza Pizza to more people than ever before. Whether you’re in the Newark, Ohio area just visiting or have lived there for a long time, try Plaza Pizza. Perhaps it will capture your heart the way it has those of loyal customers for over 50 years.

< Older Post

Newer Post >

Beyond Pineapple: Unconventional Pizza Toppings Would They Actually Work?

By Cedi Walterson Pagdalian • March 12, 2025

At Plaza Pizza, we take pride in serving classic, time-tested favorites that our customers love.

Torpedo Subs & Garlic Bread: Plaza Pizza Ohio’s Must-Try Favorites

February 21, 2025

L egendary pizza and mouthwatering sides at Plaza Pizza Ohio are local favorites. While their thin-crust pizzas steal the spotlight, two menu items that customers rave about are the Torpedo Sub and Garlic Bread . These delicious options make the perfect complement to any meal—or a meal on their own! The Torpedo Sub : A Toasted Masterpiece Plaza Pizza’s Torpedo Sub is a flavor-packed combination of premium ingredients stacked on a perfectly toasted hoagie . This savory sandwich includes: Ham, cheese, and salami Freshly sliced tomato, onion, banana peppers, and cucumber A touch of mayo for a creamy finish Want to make it even better? You can customize it with extra toppings such as: Italian dressing Pizza sauce Extra garlic At just $6.99 , this sub is a go-to favorite for anyone craving a hot, fresh, and satisfying bite! Garlic Bread : The Ultimate Sidekick A great pizza meal isn’t complete without Garlic Bread , and Plaza Pizza does it just right. Their 9-inch hoagie bun is slathered in house-made garlic butter , sprinkled with oregano , and toasted to golden perfection . Every order comes with a side of their signature marinara sauce , making it the perfect appetizer or complement to any dish. Want to level up your garlic bread game? Try the Garlic Bread with Cheese , which adds a gooey layer of melted perfection . Garlic Bread – $3.99 Garlic Bread with Cheese – $4.99 Both are available with extra garlic butter, Italian dressing, marinara sauce, or ranch for just $0.99 more !

7 Creative Toppings for Your Plaza Pizza Cauliflower Crust Pizza

December 11, 2024

For those who crave the delicious flavors of Plaza Pizza but want a lighter twist, the cauliflower crust pizza is an excellent choice. This low-carb, gluten-friendly alternative has become a favorite among those seeking a healthier way to enjoy pizza without sacrificing taste.

Who Has the Best Thin-Crust Pizza Near Me? A Slice of Perfection at Plaza Pizza

November 4, 2024

When craving the unmistakable crunch and savory flavor of thin-crust pizza, there’s nothing like finding a place that nails that perfect balance. Thin-crust enthusiasts know the joy of each bite—delicate yet satisfying, crispy without being too dense, and topped with just the right amount of sauce and cheese. If you’re wondering, “Who has the best thin-crust pizza near me ?” the answer might be closer than you think. Plaza Pizza is renowned for its thin crust done to perfection, offering a pizza experience that stands out from the competition. What Makes Plaza Pizza’s Thin-Crust the Best ? 1. Handcrafted Dough with Authentic Flavor Plaza Pizza starts with a traditional dough rolled to perfection, delivering a light and crispy crust. Each pizza crust is baked until golden, with the perfect texture that’s just as delightful on its own as it is with toppings. 2. Fresh Ingredients in Every Bite From ripe tomatoes to the finest mozzarella, Plaza Pizza doesn’t compromise quality. Their toppings are always fresh, balancing rich flavors with a delicate crust that enhances each ingredient’s natural taste. Whether you’re a fan of the classic or crave adventurous toppings, you’ll experience freshness in every slice. 3. The Art of a Perfect Bake Baking a thin-crust pizza to perfection requires attention to timing and temperature, and Plaza Pizza has mastered it. Each pizza emerges from the oven with a golden, crispy crust, ideal for folding or savoring slice by slice. 4. Customizable Options for Every Pizza Lover Plaza Pizza offers a variety of options so you can personalize your thin-crust pizza experience. They cater to diverse tastes and dietary needs, providing vegetarian, meat, and gluten-free options without compromising quality or taste. Top Toppings to Try on Plaza Pizza’s Thin-Crust To truly appreciate Plaza Pizza’s craftsmanship, try pairing your thin crust with some of their most popular toppings: ALL THE MEATS PIZZA : Meat lover's favorite! Pepperoni, bacon, ham, sausage, hamburger. ALL THE WAY PIZZA : Pepperoni, mushroom, onion, green pepper, green olive, banana pepper. BBQ CHICKEN PIZZA: BBQ base sauce, chicken, red onion, pineapple. Topped with BBQ sauce drizzle and chopped cilantro. BLT PIZZA: Placed into the oven with bacon and sauce. When it comes out, we top it with lettuce and tomato. BUFFALO CHICKEN PIZZA: It's cooked with Buffalo sauce and chicken. When it's done, we add more chicken and top it with more buffalo sauce, ranch, and green onion. VEGGIE PIZZA: It's All the Way but without pepperoni! It's made with mushrooms, onion, green, olive, and banana pepper. SHIRLEY LOU PIZZA: Named after the owner's late grandmother, it has house-made apple pie filling, streusel topping, and icing. Why Choose Plaza Pizza for Your Next Thin-Crust? Plaza Pizza’s focus on quality ingredients, precise baking methods, and commitment to great flavor make it a go-to spot for thin-crust pizza fans. With an array of toppings and an emphasis on crafting each pizza to satisfy, it’s no wonder that Plaza Pizza is frequently the answer to “Who has the best thin-crust pizza near me?” For thin-crust lovers seeking a delicious, crunchy, and flavor-packed pizza, Plaza Pizza promises an experience worth every bite. Next time you’re craving pizza perfection, give their thin crust a try and see why it’s loved by so many!

Mastering Pizza: History, Storage, and the Best Reheating Techniques

October 28, 2024

When it comes to comfort food, few things can rival a delicious pizza. Whether you’re enjoying a hot, fresh slice from the “best pizza near me now” or savoring the leftovers the next day, pizza has a charm that’s hard to resist.

Healthy and Tasty: Cauliflower Crust Pizza Near You

September 24, 2024

Pizza is undeniably one of the most beloved foods around the world. However, traditional pizza might not always fit into your meal plan if you’re aiming for a healthier lifestyle or managing dietary restrictions.