Plaza Pizza Baking Delicious Pizza in Newark, Ohio

What are some of the definitive opinions about pizza in Ohio?

People have definite opinions about pizza in Newark, Ohio. Since 1971, one of those opinions is that Plaza Pizza® is some of the best pizza around. Let’s take a look at some of the reasons why this pizzeria has achieved its recognition!

How Plaza Pizza® in Newark, Ohio Stands Out Above the Competition

So how do we do it?

The original Plaza Pizza® owners understood the love Ohioans have for pizza back in 1971, when the flagship location opened in Newark, Ohio. Because of this, they took great care in developing the Plaza Pizza® menu, and that menu holds up today as some of the best pizza in Ohio.

The commitment Plaza Pizza® developed toward great tasting pizza starts with top quality ingredients. They’re an absolute necessity for the proprietary recipes the original Plaza Pizza® owners perfected over the years with the traditional pizza sauce. They also offered many classic topping choices, which are part of what makes pizza such a fantastic and versatile food.

Visit a Signature Pizza Palace in Newark

Perhaps the most convincing factor that puts Plaza Pizza® in Newark, Ohio on the pizza map is the signature thin crust. It’s got a cracker crunch that’s incredibly satisfying to bite into.

These elements are the recipe that turned Plaza Pizza® into a pizza palace in Newark.

The Next Generation of Plaza Pizza®

As with all things, the season for the original owners of Plaza Pizza® began to wind down, and they expressed a desire to retire.

However, the Claggett family were not yet ready to let go of the Plaza Pizza® flavors that had been a staple part of some of their most cherished childhood memories and family moments. With the blessing of the rest of the family, Brian, Olivia, and Ben Claggett purchased Plaza Pizza® from the original owners in 2019.

Pizza lovers in Newark, Heath, and Newark, Ohio were all relieved this beloved institution received a second chance at another 50 (or more!) years as a pizza destination.

Bringing Plaza Pizza® to More Customers Than Ever Before

The Claggetts have always loved the flavors of Plaza Pizza® in Newark, Ohio, but they also recognized when they took over that there was potential to improve the way the business was conducted.

What’s improved is how customers can order from Plaza Pizza®. Gone are the old cash-only payment requirements and order-by-phone methods. Now, customers can order their favorite pizza of Newark, Ohio from Plaza Pizza® directly on the website or from the Toast Takeout app. We’ve also upgraded our Point-of-Sales system to allow for debit/credit card payments for more convenience to our customers.

An Expanded Menu for Plaza Pizza® in Newark, Ohio and Beyond

The same great flavors of Plaza Pizza® are still in place because the proprietary recipes and traditional cooking methods have not changed. Customers can still order their pizza favorites and enjoy Plaza Pizza® for their family get-togethers, children’s birthdays, Sunday football parties, or any other occasion where pizza will hit the spot.

While we did not upgrade what was already working well for Plaza Pizza®, we have added to the menu to bring more choice to some of our discerning customers looking for some excitement in their pizza options. After all, we’re passionate about pizza, too, and we love those opinions!

We’ve added a BLT Pizza that puts a sizzle in each bite. It goes into the oven with the bacon and sauce, and when it emerges, we top it with fresh lettuce and tomato for that beautiful BLT flavor combination so many people love.

Another menu addition is the BBQ Chicken Pizza, with a BBQ sauce base, chicken, bacon, red onion, and pineapple. It’s then drizzled with more BBQ sauce and sprinkled with freshly chopped cilantro. It’s a recipe sure to make BBQ lovers smile and go for another slice.

Find Your Favorite Pizza near Newark

Looking for a little more zing on your pizza? Then Plaza Pizza® in Newark, Ohio has you covered with the Buffalo Chicken Pizza. It goes into the oven with a Buffalo sauce base and chicken. When it emerges, we put on more chicken, add green onion, and drizzle even more Buffalo sauce and ranch over it all.

Today’s pizza lover may love pizza, but pizza may not be as kind to them. At a time when diets are more nuanced, we’ve added a cauliflower crust to our menu. It’s low-carb, and we’ll be happy to put any toppings, including specialty toppings, on your cauliflower crust pizza. The beautiful part is that it crunches very similarly to our proprietary thin crust recipe, so Plaza Pizza® lovers are still getting that satisfying snap with each bite no matter the crust they choose.

The Future is Bright for Plaza Pizza® Traditions

The Claggett family is very excited to continue Plaza Pizza® traditions for another 50 years, while also serving our customers with modern ordering methods. We’re also pleased to keep our fingers on the pulse of pizza passions, so lovers of pizza in Newark, Ohio, and beyond can count on us to bring them the best pizza in the Crust Belt!

If you’d like a traditional pizza, a new flavor, or to order your family’s favorite, stop by, call, or order online, and we’ll be happy to be the ones serving up dinner tonight!